The Odyssey (2026) Review: Christopher Nolan Understands Homer Better Than You Think... Even When He Changes Him

There may not be a director better suited to adapt The Odyssey than Christopher Nolan. People tend to treat Homer’s epic as a simple adventure story about a man trying to get home after a war, but the poem has never been that straightforward. Characters tell stories inside other stories, the timeline jumps around, and we learn about Odysseus’ journey the way his audience does, through his own retelling. If anyone was going to embrace that structure instead of flattening it, it was Nolan, and he does what he does best, which is mess with time. Scenes mirror each other and change meaning when you look back on them, the editing keeps asking you to connect the pieces yourself, and Ludwig Göransson’s score ties it together. By the final act, the opening echoes so strongly that the whole journey feels cyclical instead of linear. Structurally, it’s really smart. As an adaptation, less.

I was surprised by how much I enjoyed it. I went in expecting to spend two and a half hours comparing every scene to Homer, and instead I ended up appreciating it as Nolan’s interpretation of one of the oldest stories we have. It isn’t especially faithful. Whole episodes are condensed or cut, several characters don’t exist, and some relationships are fundamentally changed. But I don’t think he was trying to make the faithful version.

One of the first things I noticed was the film’s repeated references to “Zeus’s law,” which, unless I’m forgetting a line, isn’t how Homer talks about it. What the film means is xenia, the sacred bond between host and guest that shaped nearly every interaction in the Greek world. Hospitality was a religious obligation protected by Zeus himself, and strangers were meant to be welcomed, fed, and respected before anyone asked their name. Almost every encounter in the poem comes down to whether people will honor that bond or violate it. I wish Nolan had trusted the audience with the real word, since “Zeus’s law” loses some of the depth of a very specific Greek idea. Still, the movie understands what xenia represents. The Cyclopes reject hospitality entirely, and they eat their guests. That makes them barbaric, and it isn’t just because they’re giants. They’ve abandoned the customs that separate civilization from chaos.

My most conflicted opinion is about Circe. I was relieved that Nolan didn’t oversexualize her, because so many adaptations reduce her to the seductive witch as if that’s the only interesting thing about her. But I think he swings too far the other way. Here she’s mostly defined by violence that men committed against her when they ignored “Zeus’s law,” and that strips away some of her complexity. She’s a goddess and a nymph who is compassionate in some moments and terrifying in others. She turns men into pigs because she’s powerful, and power in Greek mythology is never uncomplicated. I appreciated that Nolan gave her humanity, but I wanted her to have more agency too. Calypso gets a similar treatment. I wouldn’t call her portrayal inaccurate, but she feels simplified. In the poem she’s lonely and genuinely loves Odysseus, even if that love becomes possessive, and the discomfort of that relationship is the point. It doesn’t fit neatly into hero and villain.

My biggest criticism is Odysseus himself. The film presents him mainly as a man desperate to get back to the wife he loves, and that is part of who he is, but only part. What has always fascinated me about him is how contradictory he is. He’s compassionate and manipulative, generous and selfish, brilliant but constantly undone by his pride. He’s fiercely loyal to Penelope while spending years with Circe and Calypso and fathering children along the way. He lies, he cheats, and he survives by becoming whoever the moment requires. He’s one of literature’s first antiheroes, and Nolan smooths out most of that mess. The result is easier to root for and, to me, less interesting.

That’s most obvious in the Cyclops sequence, or at least the version of it we got, because I can’t believe Nolan left out the “Nobody” joke. When Polyphemus asks Odysseus his name, Odysseus says “Nobody.” After he blinds the Cyclops, the other Cyclopes come running and ask what’s wrong, and Polyphemus cries, “Nobody is killing me!” So they assume no one is attacking him and leave. It’s one of the funniest moments in Greek literature, and it also tells you everything about Odysseus: his best weapon is language, and he beats monsters with his mind before he ever uses force. Then Homer adds the part that matters even more. As Odysseus sails away, he can’t resist the glory of what he’s done and shouts his real name back at Polyphemus. That lets Polyphemus pray to Poseidon, who punishes Odysseus for years, so one moment of pride sets up the rest of the epic. He’s clever enough to get out of nearly anything, but he’s too proud to leave quietly. Without that scene, the film loses one of the clearest windows into his character.

There’s a lot to praise, though. The performances are excellent across the board. Agamemnon stole every second he was on screen, and I immediately wanted more of him. Anne Hathaway was phenomenal. The film is also stunning to look at. The costumes are gorgeous, even if my Classics brain couldn’t stop nitpicking, and I did wonder how everyone had access to rich black dyes centuries before they would have been common. But I’m happy to forgive that kind of inaccuracy when something looks this good. The world feels ancient, which isn’t the same as historically perfect, and I think that fits the story.

What impressed me most was the respect. The film never makes fun of Greek mythology or modernizes it beyond recognition, and when Nolan changes events, he’s usually chasing an idea instead of a spectacle. He understands that The Odyssey isn’t really about monsters. It’s about what makes someone human, and the people Odysseus meets are defined by whether they recognize that humanity in others. Those who honor hospitality survive, and those who reject it descend into barbarism. Whether you call it “Zeus’s law” or xenia, the heart of the story is still there.

Would I have loved a more faithful adaptation? Absolutely. I missed characters, relationships, and the contradictions that make Odysseus so frustrating and so fascinating. But adaptation isn’t translation, and Nolan wasn’t trying to recreate Homer line by line. He was trying to capture what it feels like to experience The Odyssey, and mostly, he succeeds.

★★★★½ (4.5/5)

Is it Homer? No. Is it one of the most ambitious and thoughtful adaptations of an ancient epic in years? Without question.xt

Our website uses cookies

Our website use cookies. By continuing, we assume your permission to deploy cookies as detailed in our Privacy Policy.