Review: The Reappearance of Rachel Price by Holly Jackson

Lalie Lours
November 16, 2024

Author: Holly Jackson
Genre: Mystery, Thriller
Published in 2024

Rating: ★★★★ – 4

“Because her disappearance was like a puzzle, and it’s human nature to want to solve a puzzle, don’t you think?”

– The Reappearance of Rachel Price

Known for her gripping narratives and morally complex characters, Jackson delivers yet again with this mystery about trust, memory, and the secrets families hide.

When Rachel Price reappears years after vanishing on a cold winter night, her daughter Annabel “Bel” is thrust into a storm of unanswered questions. Rachel’s sudden return during the filming of a true crime documentary leaves Bel suspicious and determined to uncover the truth about her mother’s disappearance—and her family’s hidden past.

– Annabel “Bel” Price –

Bel’s journey is the heart of the story. Her character is both determined and vulnerable as she pieces together fragments of her past while questioning everything she thought she knew about her family.

– Rachel Price –

Rachel is a mystery unto herself. Her behavior is both cryptic and unsettling, and Jackson keeps readers on edge as they, like Bel, try to figure out whether Rachel is a victim or hiding something sinister.

– My Honest Review –

Having read all of Jackson’s books, I was thrilled by how The Reappearance of Rachel Price combines tension with a deeply personal, character-driven narrative. The true crime documentary angle adds a new twist, unseen in Jackson’s novels before. 

The writing is atmospheric, the twists are brilliantly crafted, and the themes of trust and betrayal resonate long after the final page.

While the pacing slows slightly in the middle, the explosive final act more than makes up for it. The Reappearance of Rachel Price is not only my favorite Jackson book but also a must-read for fans of thrillers and mysteries packed with emotional depth.

Happy Reading!

You MaY ALSO LIKE
Dance of Thieves Review: Clever Heists, Romance, and Political Intrigue
August 30, 2025
Dance of Thieves Review: Clever Heists, Romance, and Political Intrigue

Author: Mary E. PearsonGenre: YA Fantasy / RomancePublished: 2018Rating: ★★★☆☆ – 3.5/5…

Anne of Green Gables Review: A Timeless Classic About Imagination and Belonging
August 24, 2025
Anne of Green Gables Review: A Timeless Classic About Imagination and Belonging

Author: L. M. MontgomeryGenre: Children’s Literature / Classic FictionPublished: 1908Rating: ★★★★☆ –…

Shadow and Bone Review: Is the Grishaverse Worth Reading?
August 03, 2025
Shadow and Bone Review: Is the Grishaverse Worth Reading?

Shadow and BoneAuthor: Leigh BardugoGenre: YA FantasyPublished: 2012Rating: ★★★★☆ – 4/5 “The…

Leave a reply
Leave a reply